Mark Rosewater, the head designer of Magic, always says that is important that a card should be as close as possibile by his oracle text by just reading it and that you should get all the correct infos about it without having the paranoia to check the gatherer for every single card just to be sure you are playing it correctly. So why they are so damn inconsistent about their own criteria?
- creature types erratas.
usually when they introduce new creature types, they also retroactively make the old creatures fitting that type of that type...except when they dont. why so? a total mistery, Mark always refused to elaborate further when asked, so apparently its total arbitrary:
https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/813524331551473664/why-did-book-get-an-errata-of-multiple-cards
https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/812983092131266560/hi-mark-i-noticed-the-book-errata-on-codie-and
https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/740441727644598272/dogged-detective-got-a-reprint-in-the-commander
https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/828407288203247616/i-just-wish-to-complain-that-making-dragon-engine
https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/744584329669263360/mark-i-was-wondering-why-did-relic-sloth-and-a
Case on point : [[Dogged Detective]] . He's a literal detective, yet when they introduced the detective type on Murders on Karlov Manor, they didnt made a detective him or any other guy or gal that is clearly detective lorewise. Is it because it would take too much to errata? that didnt stop the massive retroactive phyrexian creature type errata over 500 cards in all magic history, and even then, MaRo said so many times on his blog that that should had been a ship already sailed, see here:
"Ā The problem was that the Phyrexians had been in Magic many times in many sets which made it very odd that these Phyrexians would be Phyrexians but the old ones would not.Ā
Why not just errata all the old Phyrexian cards? Because while it is clear what is and isnāt Phyrexian from someone in the know, we canāt expect all players to have that kind of knowledge."
https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/21445479604/was-using-phyrexian-as-a-creature-type-ever
"The problem is there are characters that are clearly Phyrexian by flavor and not making those Phyrexian would upset a different group of players. Like many things in Magic, twenty-five tears of history and inertia make some changes hard to do."
https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/169049821833/if-you-cant-tell-if-a-creature-is-phyrexian-then
Ironically enough, not only all the "we canāt expect all players to have that kind of knowledge" was thrown to trash after the massive update after Phyrexia: All is One set, but even the "characters that are clearly Phyrexian by flavor and not making those Phyrexian would upset a different group of players" part they failed completely with cases like Witch Engine or Consecrated Sphinx that should be Phyrexians after all the errata mess they did but for mysterious reasons arent (and the "Sphinx got non-phyrexian printings" is also an inconsistent argument, since also Wurmcoil Engine get several non-phyrexian printings and is still a phyrexian, same thing for Western and Eastern paladin case)
So its because the opposite reason, not bother to errata because the tribe isnt worthed to be supported retroactively because there are only a bunch of cases? even that is not true, because they literally made, when they made the Warlock creature type, [[Dread Warlock]] a warlock as the ONLY ONE simply because it got warlock in the name, and Moriok Rigger, a rigger, despite, again, being the ONLY ONE that retroactively received the errata, so that means that literally nothing stops them to do creature types erratas if not their whims. The most honest answer MaRo itself ever gave was in fact "Ā Iām honestly not sure what prompts us doing it when we do**.**"
- power level erratas : a card must work as printed or as intended?
let's talk about the "power level" and "functional" errata, something that today shouldn't exist anymore (that's why Time Vault works today as printed despite being super broken and banned everywhere). But here's the inconsistency and incongruency of erratas policy:
- Phyrexian Dreadnought for example is a card that for today rules works as printed, but not as intended, because when was printed stack wasn't a thing and it was not possibile to avoid the cost thanks to Stifle. Which is possible today. but wait, because we got also Lotus Vale, Scorched Ruins, Mox Diamond and other cards from the same period that got the exact wording of the Phyrexian Dreadnought, and yet were errated with a different criteria, to works as intended but not as printed despite what their abilities means today in modern rules. Why so? Apparently just because Stifling a Dreadnought seemed ok but 2 lands that works as a black lotus was too much. Ah, but so, that was a power level and functional errata, what WotC said to avoid and that's why we have the super-broken Time Vault works just as printed despite being being even arguably much more broken and degenerate than a lotus.
So here's the first problem : cards worded exactly with the same template, from the same period, threated differently in a merely arbitrary way, making literally impossible for players to know how to interpret by their own logic those cards without seeing the gatherer (which is the fail of WotC intent to strictly errata the cards in a way that are much adherent as the original printed text as possible).
Second case : Master of Arms. A card that today works as printed but not as intended, because tapping a creature that is already blocking does absolutely nothing in order to prevent damage, while Master or Arms works in a way that his ability exist exactly why he could "shut down" the creature damages with the old rules, making it completely useless now.
And guess what. WotC now decided to print instead Torpor Orb, Howling Mine and other old artifacts with the "if it's untapped" clause, to match the functionality with the older rules, making this cards works as intended (for Icy Manipulator combos and such), but not as printed
Again, I hate the inconsistency here. Both Master of Arms and Howling Mine have invisibile, non written rules in their original card text that imply things in the old rule system. But for some reasons, WotC had the arbitrary idea to make visibile the invisibile rule system working othe Mine, but not to make visibile the necessary one to give a sense to Master of Arms. Why so? Who knows. Either case, players are, again, confused as hell, because it's just impossibile to tell how should work a card following a strictly, logical and coherent criteria without following the arbitrary messing of wotc erratas. (and also Reconnneisance now give for example pseudo-vigilance to all your creatures without any drawback despite that's not how the card was supposed to work as intended at all when was originally printed)
and dont let me getting start with the elephant in the room...how they handled the noncombat damage redirection rule on planeswalkers and subsequent abolition of that rule. Now the new players that must learn the game, must know that for the first 25 years of the game noncombat damage on creatures and players means "any target (so now even battles, or sometimes not)" "target player" means "player or planeswalker" and all that doesnt apply for all cards printed after the set Dominaria on 2018, but you just do as printed so "target player" means ony player in that case. What a mess.
- power level erratas : buffing and nerfing the cards for no real good reasons.
both [[Ajani's Pridemate]] and [[Rampaging Baloths]] have the "may" removed from their original text so now their ability is mandatory. And is not that they made the change for all "may" cards, no no. only these two. How the hell a player both playing with or against the first printings of the cards should know or deduce this or having the need to check the gatherer? no idea.
[[Loxodon Warhammer]] had a triggered and cumulative ability of gaining life for several printings until they give it lifelink and never restore the original functionality back.
[[Werewolf Pack Leader]] got very recently a power level errata nerf because apparently the FOUR CARD jank combo he could make previously was too much to handle for the sake of all Magic casual and competitive long term health of the game. Sure.
but on the other hand, frickin [[Flying Carpet]] lost the "destroy the flying carpet if the creature it targeted is destroyed", making much less flavorful but hey...now without the sucky drawback is a powerhouse played everywhere right?
- misprint erratas
Riding the Pilu Horse vs Hostage Taker, Invert / Invent, Oboro Envoy Marath and other cards.
Riding the Dilu Horse wording was a misprinting. The pump effect was never intended to last indefinitely. Here's the original FAQ of Portal 3 Kingdoms:
Q. Is the bonus from Riding the Dilu Horse permanent?
A. No, because the card should read, "Any one creature gets +2/+2 and gains horsemanship until end of turn."
And what the currently Oracle Text says about this card? Yes, the bonus from Riding the Dilu Horse is permanent.
- So, Riding the Dilu Horse is a misprinted card that has no duration of his effect for mere error, and works exactly as printed but not as intended.
why so? "Because it is important that players can see the cards and understand themselves how the cards works, by just reading them"
- Invert / Invent, Oboro Envoy and others are also, like Riding the Pilu Horse, misprinted cards that has no duration of their effect for mere error, and works exactly as intended but not as printed.
Why so? Because this time, apparently "**** players, we don't pay for our errors, just read the damn gatherer and shut up."
Sorry for the long rant, but as a player that love the mathematical precision and care of this game with his monumental Comprehensive Rules that is written like a legal code to hold everything together with a 100% correct answer on literally anything, its infuriating when WotC are so careless about the card errating and sometimes when you teach the game to new players it seems almost you are scamming them and lose their trust when those or many other cases like this pop up even in casual games.
TL; DR: wotc errating thing is an ugly mess. here I explain exactly why and where. the list is non-exhaustive, but just examples.