r/mtg • • 21h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help So No Chakotay? *Breaks Skateboard*

2 Upvotes

UB criticism aside, I've been loving the new Star Trek set, I'm a huge Star Trek fan, so of course I'm eating this up.

But its taken me until now, trying to build a Janeway, Endgame deck, that I realise there's no Chakotay anywhere in this set..?

Its reasonable to assume they couldn't fit EVERYONE, they've tried to fit 60 years of television in this set, even made the effort to acknowledge Prodigy and Lower Decks, if not Academy. But this feels suspicious, every member of Voyagers bridge crew has got a card, except Chakotay, who appears in none of the art, flavour text, or even promotional material.

So what the hell is up with that? I don't think its like Avery Brooks who's spent the rest of his life keeping Star Trek at arms length, I'm relatively sure Robert Beltran is happy with the role and makes plenty of con appearances. Were they afraid of appropriating or misrepresenting Native American culture in his rules text or art?

Thanks for the help, loves 😊

Edit: Thanks to Ramses_Overdark who linked a [Better developed thread] (https://www.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/s/HrDF7vaE2q) on another sub.


r/mtg • • 1h ago

Discussion 2026 the good, the bad, the ugly. Let’s talk about it

0 Upvotes

I was going to start this two days ago, and then the insufferable industry plant dropped his wotc preferred list for the sets of 2026, so I figured I’d stir the pot. ā€œInfluencer statusā€ aside, what are your takes the sets of 2026.

I am not here to yuck someone else’s yum. While I may not support some of the business practices, I do support the game itself, and the people who play. And this is a discussion to hear everyone’s thoughts. For background, I started playing magic in alpha, and have been loosely on and off, but seriously got back into it four years ago. I build mostly commander, because that’s what is available and no one plays standard near me anymore. But I feel Prerelease is truly some of the best magic, and go to each event to get a feel for each set. And I love Universes Beyond, but i feel like they don’t get the same treatment from core sets, and get labeled as slop due to the mass production. So worst to first, let’s get after it.

8. Mystery commander- personally, I’ve got no time for this. This admittedly is a bunch of rejects that didn’t make standard legal sets, wrapped up with a fancy foil sleeve and charged a premium. This is prime corporate greed. If you sit down with a deck of 3000 cards or any other rule breaker, count me out. I just don’t find this fun, and fundamentally a disservice to you the player.

7- The Hobbit- Boom. Worst set this year. And I will readily admit that part of this decision is weighted on the audacity of the pricing. And before we move on, if the One Ring wasn’t reprinted, would this set be anywhere close to that? The archetypes were meh, kinda boring and listless, and genuinely a letdown. I accidentally bought a booster box, and when I finally opened it, was thoroughly underwhelmed with what was there. Now I will never turn down the addition of more elves to add to the ball, and there are some gorgeous lands, but I got my gleaming splendor, and I’m gonna move on.

6- Star Trek- Now it’s still very new, and maybe time will tell, but this one kinda missed the mark for me. Artwork is a large proponent of the game to me, and this wasn’t it. Full art shocklands were rad. But the reprints shouldn’t be what holds up a set, and personally I think sheoldred and bristly bill got done dirty on this one. Also the autographed cards feel especially grimy. A lot of this scream to me ā€œbad business practiceā€ than what’s going to be good for the game. However, the borg are gonna be really cool, it’s just too bad that we probably won’t be going back for more borg cards in a Star Trek 2 series.

5. Lorwyn Eclipsed- this is hard for me, because I liked this a lot. It was beautiful. It’s whimsical. But it’s a little soft. There were so many great cards, for so many fun deck options, but a little underwhelming on their own. But I’ve got a handful thrown into all my decks at the moment. I like dance of the elements, but it never seems to pop for me, and I ultimately broke down auntie ool, because you get targeted very quickly, regardless of a weak board.

4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles- it’s my list I can do what I want. This was my most anticipated set of the year. I was a huge turtle fan as a kid, and was so stoked when it was announced. I do love this set, I’ve made a ton of decks surrounding it. But I do feel cheated at the same time. The turtle precon is my favorite precon to come out this year. It’s competitive out of the box, it’s fun, and you have so many choices and directions to go in. But the repetitiveness is insane. How many white Leonardos do you need to print? Could you not dig a little deeper?
As a sidenote, I went to 2 prerelease for this, and got unlucky and properly stumped both times. But still, I think this set gets unjustly hated for being turtles, when it should be getting disliked for not being given the same care, to say, secrets of strixhaven.

3. Marvel Superheroes- I could have dropped this lower, but there really were a lot of good, powerful cards in here. Again, I like UB, and this got treatment most similar to Final Fantasy than Spiderman. Summer is a hard time to release a card game, we’ve all seen an official excessive amount of marvel, and I think we can all agree secret lair needs a new cash cow. But it plays well, and again, it’s definitely raised the power creep. But it does it with the subtlety of a spiked bat.

2. Reality Fracture- these last two, I could be happy flip flopping repeatedly. When I heard I could get a blue Chandra, you already had me. This set plays into jaces mind of madness perfectly. There are more plays to be made, and a ton of creativity and thought of characters and lore and history, and then the implications of the butterfly effect in this reality. Its beautiful. And i like planeswalkers getting so much love. The commitment to the echo pairs is double-edged, where it’s awesome at first, but leads to an insane amount of doubles in my collection, but im going to mark this a win. I would have been happy with another month to this season.

  1. Secrets of Strixhaven- this set did so much right. The spells are crisp and clean, the characters are great. The choice of which collage you would represent, I proudly support Witherbloom. The art was great, and the mystical archives were amazing. It made reprints seamlessly feel like it should have been there from the start. I loved the Japanese cards, except I can’t read Japanese, but the art was phenomenal. This set fully surpassed my expectations, and I’m going to await a return to strixhaven.

So that’s mine. Tell me what you think you’d change, and let’s keep it clean. Remember that even if your opponent is playing UB, they are still playing magic. If anyone sees Ben bateman, kick him in the nuts for me.


r/mtg • • 14h ago

Discussion wotc absolute inconsistencies on errating they own cards

0 Upvotes

Mark Rosewater, the head designer of Magic, always says that is important that a card should be as close as possibile by his oracle text by just reading it and that you should get all the correct infos about it without having the paranoia to check the gatherer for every single card just to be sure you are playing it correctly. So why they are so damn inconsistent about their own criteria?

- creature types erratas.

usually when they introduce new creature types, they also retroactively make the old creatures fitting that type of that type...except when they dont. why so? a total mistery, Mark always refused to elaborate further when asked, so apparently its total arbitrary:

https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/813524331551473664/why-did-book-get-an-errata-of-multiple-cards

https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/812983092131266560/hi-mark-i-noticed-the-book-errata-on-codie-and

https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/740441727644598272/dogged-detective-got-a-reprint-in-the-commander

https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/828407288203247616/i-just-wish-to-complain-that-making-dragon-engine

https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/744584329669263360/mark-i-was-wondering-why-did-relic-sloth-and-a

Case on point : [[Dogged Detective]] . He's a literal detective, yet when they introduced the detective type on Murders on Karlov Manor, they didnt made a detective him or any other guy or gal that is clearly detective lorewise. Is it because it would take too much to errata? that didnt stop the massive retroactive phyrexian creature type errata over 500 cards in all magic history, and even then, MaRo said so many times on his blog that that should had been a ship already sailed, see here:

"Ā The problem was that the Phyrexians had been in Magic many times in many sets which made it very odd that these Phyrexians would be Phyrexians but the old ones would not.Ā 

Why not just errata all the old Phyrexian cards? Because while it is clear what is and isn’t Phyrexian from someone in the know, we can’t expect all players to have that kind of knowledge."
https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/21445479604/was-using-phyrexian-as-a-creature-type-ever

"The problem is there are characters that are clearly Phyrexian by flavor and not making those Phyrexian would upset a different group of players. Like many things in Magic, twenty-five tears of history and inertia make some changes hard to do."

https://markrosewater.tumblr.com/post/169049821833/if-you-cant-tell-if-a-creature-is-phyrexian-then

Ironically enough, not only all the "we can’t expect all players to have that kind of knowledge" was thrown to trash after the massive update after Phyrexia: All is One set, but even the "characters that are clearly Phyrexian by flavor and not making those Phyrexian would upset a different group of players" part they failed completely with cases like Witch Engine or Consecrated Sphinx that should be Phyrexians after all the errata mess they did but for mysterious reasons arent (and the "Sphinx got non-phyrexian printings" is also an inconsistent argument, since also Wurmcoil Engine get several non-phyrexian printings and is still a phyrexian, same thing for Western and Eastern paladin case)

So its because the opposite reason, not bother to errata because the tribe isnt worthed to be supported retroactively because there are only a bunch of cases? even that is not true, because they literally made, when they made the Warlock creature type, [[Dread Warlock]] a warlock as the ONLY ONE simply because it got warlock in the name, and Moriok Rigger, a rigger, despite, again, being the ONLY ONE that retroactively received the errata, so that means that literally nothing stops them to do creature types erratas if not their whims. The most honest answer MaRo itself ever gave was in fact "Ā I’m honestly not sure what prompts us doing it when we do**.**"

- power level erratas : a card must work as printed or as intended?

let's talk about the "power level" and "functional" errata, something that today shouldn't exist anymore (that's why Time Vault works today as printed despite being super broken and banned everywhere). But here's the inconsistency and incongruency of erratas policy:

- Phyrexian Dreadnought for example is a card that for today rules works as printed, but not as intended, because when was printed stack wasn't a thing and it was not possibile to avoid the cost thanks to Stifle. Which is possible today. but wait, because we got also Lotus Vale, Scorched Ruins, Mox Diamond and other cards from the same period that got the exact wording of the Phyrexian Dreadnought, and yet were errated with a different criteria, to works as intended but not as printed despite what their abilities means today in modern rules. Why so? Apparently just because Stifling a Dreadnought seemed ok but 2 lands that works as a black lotus was too much. Ah, but so, that was a power level and functional errata, what WotC said to avoid and that's why we have the super-broken Time Vault works just as printed despite being being even arguably much more broken and degenerate than a lotus.
So here's the first problem : cards worded exactly with the same template, from the same period, threated differently in a merely arbitrary way, making literally impossible for players to know how to interpret by their own logic those cards without seeing the gatherer (which is the fail of WotC intent to strictly errata the cards in a way that are much adherent as the original printed text as possible).

Second case : Master of Arms. A card that today works as printed but not as intended, because tapping a creature that is already blocking does absolutely nothing in order to prevent damage, while Master or Arms works in a way that his ability exist exactly why he could "shut down" the creature damages with the old rules, making it completely useless now.
And guess what. WotC now decided to print instead Torpor Orb, Howling Mine and other old artifacts with the "if it's untapped" clause, to match the functionality with the older rules, making this cards works as intended (for Icy Manipulator combos and such), but not as printed
Again, I hate the inconsistency here. Both Master of Arms and Howling Mine have invisibile, non written rules in their original card text that imply things in the old rule system. But for some reasons, WotC had the arbitrary idea to make visibile the invisibile rule system working othe Mine, but not to make visibile the necessary one to give a sense to Master of Arms. Why so? Who knows. Either case, players are, again, confused as hell, because it's just impossibile to tell how should work a card following a strictly, logical and coherent criteria without following the arbitrary messing of wotc erratas. (and also Reconnneisance now give for example pseudo-vigilance to all your creatures without any drawback despite that's not how the card was supposed to work as intended at all when was originally printed)

and dont let me getting start with the elephant in the room...how they handled the noncombat damage redirection rule on planeswalkers and subsequent abolition of that rule. Now the new players that must learn the game, must know that for the first 25 years of the game noncombat damage on creatures and players means "any target (so now even battles, or sometimes not)" "target player" means "player or planeswalker" and all that doesnt apply for all cards printed after the set Dominaria on 2018, but you just do as printed so "target player" means ony player in that case. What a mess.

- power level erratas : buffing and nerfing the cards for no real good reasons.

both [[Ajani's Pridemate]] and [[Rampaging Baloths]] have the "may" removed from their original text so now their ability is mandatory. And is not that they made the change for all "may" cards, no no. only these two. How the hell a player both playing with or against the first printings of the cards should know or deduce this or having the need to check the gatherer? no idea.

[[Loxodon Warhammer]] had a triggered and cumulative ability of gaining life for several printings until they give it lifelink and never restore the original functionality back.

[[Werewolf Pack Leader]] got very recently a power level errata nerf because apparently the FOUR CARD jank combo he could make previously was too much to handle for the sake of all Magic casual and competitive long term health of the game. Sure.

but on the other hand, frickin [[Flying Carpet]] lost the "destroy the flying carpet if the creature it targeted is destroyed", making much less flavorful but hey...now without the sucky drawback is a powerhouse played everywhere right?

- misprint erratas

Riding the Pilu Horse vs Hostage Taker, Invert / Invent, Oboro Envoy Marath and other cards.

Riding the Dilu Horse wording was a misprinting. The pump effect was never intended to last indefinitely. Here's the original FAQ of Portal 3 Kingdoms:
Q. Is the bonus from Riding the Dilu Horse permanent?

A. No, because the card should read, "Any one creature gets +2/+2 and gains horsemanship until end of turn."

And what the currently Oracle Text says about this card? Yes, the bonus from Riding the Dilu Horse is permanent.

- So, Riding the Dilu Horse is a misprinted card that has no duration of his effect for mere error, and works exactly as printed but not as intended.
why so? "Because it is important that players can see the cards and understand themselves how the cards works, by just reading them"

- Invert / Invent, Oboro Envoy and others are also, like Riding the Pilu Horse, misprinted cards that has no duration of their effect for mere error, and works exactly as intended but not as printed.
Why so? Because this time, apparently "**** players, we don't pay for our errors, just read the damn gatherer and shut up."

Sorry for the long rant, but as a player that love the mathematical precision and care of this game with his monumental Comprehensive Rules that is written like a legal code to hold everything together with a 100% correct answer on literally anything, its infuriating when WotC are so careless about the card errating and sometimes when you teach the game to new players it seems almost you are scamming them and lose their trust when those or many other cases like this pop up even in casual games.

TL; DR: wotc errating thing is an ugly mess. here I explain exactly why and where. the list is non-exhaustive, but just examples.


r/mtg • • 1h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Is limiting myself to 60 cards or close to it hurting my deck building?

15 Upvotes

I normally play at home standard games and try not having more than 60 cards in my deck. This might be a bad habit from Yugioh, but I have this philosophy where if I need more than the minimum, then I probably don't have an efficient deck.

Is this true with Magic as well or is there a different idea that I should think about when deck building or do I just need more experience?


r/mtg • • 7h ago

Discussion Anyone else ever just wanna sell it all?

0 Upvotes

Sometimes I feel like just selling all my magic stuff, mainly because it seems hard to find anyone to actually have regular play with. Not even so much life getting in the way but more like I just can’t ever get anyone to play. I absolutely love the game since I first started, but just seems like here recently and way way more often there never ends up being anyone to play with. I’m use to having like every other Saturday commander tournaments or something and no nothing. If anyone is is OH near zanesville-Lancaster-Hebron/Heath area and ever wanted to play or have a group that’s looking for another player DM me please!

Sorry for the ā€œrantā€ just sucks because I love the game but feel like I’m falling out due to lack of playing other then on Arena but I like the feeling of real cardboard in my hands lol. Anyone else ever get this feeling?


r/mtg • • 13h ago

Rules Question How would this work?

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

I have a commander deck based around [Wasitora, Nekoru Queen] where if you deal combat damage to a player, opponent sacrifices a creature. I am curious to how an interaction would go with a [Helm of the Host] copy since it’s not legendary. If a person attacked by 2 queens, and her 4 creatures who can’t block, how many sacrifices happen. Does the ability trigger only for itself, does it both trigger for both because it sees itself and the copy as a valid activation.


r/mtg • • 9h ago

Custom Card / Alter Ocarina of Time proxy deck using mostly official art or screenshots I took in game (the game is so pretty!)

Thumbnail gallery
69 Upvotes

Posted with mod's permission

Complete temples and dungeons (collect shrines), get the Sages' help (shrine creatures) and travel time (blink and flicker) to defeat Ganondorf (... your opponents)!

See all cards and download the deck for FREE on my Ko-Fi: https://ko-fi.com/s/1959d66216

The cards are available without bleed edge (for example for Table Top Simulator) and with a 1/8th inch mirrored bleed edge (some printing services require this).

The deck should be around bracket 3, it intentionally uses some worse cards to allow for more flavor. You can see the decklist here: https://moxfield.com/decks/R3Y4VtkiUUKuv9ySBgN8uw

Should you want to upgrade the deck, feel free to make alters for your swaps. I used the "woodland" frame and the fonts are "Triforce" for Title, Typeline, and P/T, and "Hylia Serif" for rules text and original card name.


r/mtg • • 4h ago

Commander / EDH Triggered Enchantments/ artifacts

Post image
2 Upvotes

I'm currently building a Mister fantastic commander deck and could use some help. My idea is to use his effect to triple triggered effects of noncreature permanents, but I have no idea where to look for those. I was thinking of doing some fun artifacts and enchantments with triggered effects to get the most out of both of his abilities. Any suggestions?


r/mtg • • 2h ago

Commander / EDH Sonic commander. Recommendations appreciated

Post image
7 Upvotes

I am new to Magic but a bud of mine gifted me these rad sonic cards and wanted to know if i could make a decent commander deck switching out cards from a precon. I don’t plan to go competitive, I just want a fun (preferably cheap) deck šŸ˜…. Any suggestions?


r/mtg • • 14h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help If I play Finale of Revelation do I get the no maximum hand size effect

Thumbnail mtgseeker.com
0 Upvotes

Do get the no maximum hand for the rest of the game effect if I don't make X 10 or more


r/mtg • • 21h ago

Discussion Does anyone else feel like all new cards kind of feel the same?

58 Upvotes

I've been playing for about 3 years now so I'm definitely still a newer player and maybe my perspective is just wrong. But what prompted this post were the new Dune Secret Lair cards. I'm a big Dune guy but I just didn't feel all that excited from reading the cards. The Maud'Dib legendary creature feels like a card I've seen a hundred times. Something something look at the top of your library, play cards off the top when synergy is met, lands, graveyard, meh. It feels like every set regardless of the actual flavor has some effect that doubles things, some effect that cheats things into play, some effect that loads up the graveyard. And everything seems to reward you for engaging in basic game mechanics.

I wasn't playing when Storm and Dredge were originally printed as new mechanics, but they feel like they invented entirely new ways to play the game. Non-standard strategies you'd have to build around, or like a new axis of play.

I dunno. This could be really unpopular. I just can't shake the feeling that we're getting the same types of cards over and over again.


r/mtg • • 7h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Phyrexian Unlife combo deck build

Post image
0 Upvotes

I love the concept of this deck since it came out with [nine lives] it’s been a while since I played MTGA and now getting back on. Wasn’t sure if my deck is outdated.

Are there any new enchantments or cards that are a must have? I mainly play Bo1 and want to get to higher ranked with this deck. Any thoughts?

Any help would be appreciated. I’m not good at building decks and don’t have the time to play test as much as I want.


r/mtg • • 14h ago

Commander / EDH Gimme an interesting commander

0 Upvotes

I need some deck inspiration. Anyone wanna hmu to their fav weird deck strat. Would be much appreciated. What do I say from here lol i don’t want to get autodeleted for low effort.


r/mtg • • 19h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Woolies sell mtg ???

Post image
0 Upvotes

Is this a new thing ? Has anyone done it ? Is this aussie costco ?


r/mtg • • 11h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help I love creature battles, I love magic, I kinda hate the state of the game

0 Upvotes

I mean: I hate big texts, complicated mechanics, super combos, one hit kill combos, and stuff like this

I love something like "army of zombies versus army of mermaids", fairies vs wurms, humans vs vampires, thise kind of things

If you're familiar with Heroes of Might and Magic, that's kiiinda what I'd love from MTG: very few spells, a lot of fighting.

A more crude, simpler version of the game

What format should I go into?

(I mean, with my friends we can play with whatever deck we like, so, ok, but is there a competitive scene for me?)

The closer I can think of is pauper, since pauper cards are "simpler"

Mmh?


r/mtg • • 3h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help I'm new to MTG and am thinking that getting some cheap bulk might be a good way to fill out a collection of common staples? If anyone interested in downsizing their collection le me know.

33 Upvotes

I'm new to MTG and am thinking that getting some cheap bulk might be a good way to cheaply start a collection.


r/mtg • • 17h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Desk for deck building station?

0 Upvotes

I am wanting a desk for my deck building station. I want it to have plenty of room for my already built decks and card storage and binders. You know basically a one place for all my MTG needs. Does anyone have recommendations or advice?


r/mtg • • 21h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Help a lowly Boros player

Post image
4 Upvotes

Take my deck to the next level

Long time on and off magic player, but first time really building decks, below is my deck list please lmk what you would add and or/take away…thanks peeps!

Ngl I used AI to help lol cause I just have so many questions and don’t have a encyclopedic knowledge of cards

Commander
1 Lightning, Army of One (FIN) 233

Deck
16 Plains (ANB) 115
13 Mountain (AKH) 264
1 Giver of Runes (MH1) 13
1 Voice of Victory (TDM) 33
1 Ajani, Caller of the Pride (FDN) 134
1 Celestial Armor (FDN) 5
1 Akroma's Will (SOA) 1
1 Adaptive Armorer (Y26) 1
1 Stirring Hopesinger (SOS) 35
1 Leonardo's Technique (TMT) 18
1 Adagia, Windswept Bastion (EOE) 250
1 Stadium Headliner (TDM) 122
1 Inti, Seneschal of the Sun (LCI) 156
1 Molten-Core Maestro (SOS) 125
1 Samut, Hazoret's Champion (FRA) 251
1 Summon: Brynhildr (FIN) 160
1 Tend to the Kiln (Y26) 13
1 Toralf's Disciple (Y22) 44
1 Chandra, Torch of Defiance (FRA) 244
1 Enduring Courage (DSK) 133
1 The Fire Crystal (FIN) 135
1 Sunspine Lynx (BLB) 155
1 Full Throttle (DFT) 127
1 Improvisation Capstone (SOS) 120
1 Cori Mountain Monastery (TDM) 252
1 Quark's Bar (TRK) 292
1 Lindblum, Industrial Regency (FIN) 285
1 Kavaron, Memorial World (EOE) 255
1 Swiftblade Vindicator (FDN) 246
1 Anim Pakal, Thousandth Moon (LCI) 223
1 Blade Historian (STX) 165
1 Lorehold, the Historian (SOS) 201
1 Aurelia, the Warleader (FDN) 651
1 Battlefield Forge (LTC) 296
1 Sacred Foundry (TRK) 295
1 Temple of Triumph (FDN) 705
1 Sunbillow Verge (DFT) 264
1 Starting Town (FIN) 289
1 Shivan Devastator (DMU) 143
1 Divine Resilience (FDN) 10
1 Mother of Runes (ULG) 14
1 Restoration Magic (FIN) 30
1 Zack Fair (FIN) 45
1 Duty Beyond Death (SOA) 4
1 Sheltered by Ghosts (DSK) 30
1 Twinblade Blessing (FDN) 26
1 Lightning Bolt (MSC) 806
1 Abrade (FDN) 188
1 Arabella, Abandoned Doll (DSK) 208
1 Boros Signet (RVR) 251
1 Boros Charm (FDN) 721
1 Lightning Helix (MKM) 218
1 Reyav, Master Smith (MUL) 122
1 Talisman of Conviction (MH1) 230
1 Bruenor Battlehammer (AFR) 219
1 Swiftfoot Boots (BRR) 58
1 Access Tunnel (STX) 262
1 Rogue's Passage (HOC) 212
1 Burst Lightning (FDN) 192
1 Shock (ANB) 84
1 Lightning Strike (MSH) 142
1 Genji Glove (FIN) 258
1 Angelic Destiny (FDN) 565
1 Hard-Won Jitte (TMT) 91
1 Skewer the Critics (OTP) 26
1 Boltwave (FDN) 79
1 Authority of the Consuls (FDN) 137
1 Return the Favor (SOA) 47
1 Lightning Axe (SIR) 166
1 Giant Cindermaw (FDN) 624
1 Channeled Dragonfire (TDM) 102
1 Lay Down Arms (BRO) 11


r/mtg • • 23h ago

Rules Question Moving commander from Graveyard to battlefield

0 Upvotes

If somebody tries to reanimate my commander from the graveyard, am I able to choose for it to go to the command zone instead?

Ive been looking into the rules and cant find anything that tells me I can so Im assuming I cant

Edit: Beautiful responses, thanks all for your help 😁


r/mtg • • 4h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Selling bulk/what should I do?

2 Upvotes

Im not sure about how to sell my bulk and idk if I should try like card conduit but my lgs said to take it to a game x change or vintage stock. Any recommendations?


r/mtg • • 22h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help My husband loves magic and the holidays are coming up

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I am in need of some assistance for the upcoming holidays! My husband LOVES mtg and plays weekly and has an insane amount of cards.

I would really like to get him something mtg related for Christmas but I’m struggling to figure out what he would actually like.

My initial thought was something to organize/display his favorite cards in? Or maybe some mtg specific item for when he plays during the week?

Essentially, I am an absolutely baboon in the mtg world but I love my husband and I would love to support his interests.

Any recs/suggestions would be SO appreciated!


r/mtg • • 5h ago

Discussion MACO Strike Team compared to Pawpatch Recruit in Standard?

Thumbnail gallery
21 Upvotes

Put very simply, these two cards look quite similar and I was wondering what merits eaither one had over the other (if there are any), in a Mostly/Mono-Green aggro deck in Standard.


r/mtg • • 17h ago

Custom Card / Alter Found some really old proxies in some of my old bulk boxes.

Post image
12 Upvotes

Not sure who made these, but got them long ago. Still have a bunch of old legends, dark, and antiquities bulk, these were in there.

The time walk was printed onto a old water worm, not sure what the moxs are on, but it will probably also be something from that time.


r/mtg • • 2h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help I think it's time

0 Upvotes

Over the past couple years I've really gotten into magic, I've made lifelong friends and had some great games that have come down to the wire. However, I can no longer ignore the financial burden it has taken. some of my decks prices have gotten out of control and I don't think it's healthy anymore. this is not me saying I want to quit, but rather I am asking for help

I am going go through all my decks and see which one's I really enjoy using and then sell the ones that I don't. I am going to then improve the decks I enjoy and get new ones. I know that sounds -contradictory to me saying I want to cut my spending on the product, but these decks will be the last one's I ever make and use. after I complete these I will no longer buy singles or massive amounts of packs to build commander decks, standard decks, or even participate in draft. I will buy a couple play boosters and one collector booster per release because I still like the product and I don't know where the money trail goes, but if my money somehow goes to artists that's fine with me. (There's also another reason for that but I'll get to it later)

The amount of decks I want is 8, no more, no less. Most of them will be centered around universes beyond cards, but that's what got me into the game and I think some of the sets have been pretty cool and had some great mechanics. If you're still reading this you probably are wondering what those commanders will be, They are:

- Bumi, Unleashed
Objective: make lands into creatures and hit people
bracket: 4 (only because of ashaya, it also has one gamechanger in seedborn muse and no tutors(heavily considering owning one just incase I feel like making it slighlty more competitive depending on the play group))
deck progress: needs work with constantly turning lands into creatures, but I don't know if I want to get away from earthbending too much, need a decent amount of help with this deck

- Abaddon the Despolier
Objective: deals tons of damage to then go through my deck like a slot machine in a casino and spit out demons like a portal to the underworld
bracket: 3(Jeskai's will, cyclonic rift, rhystic study.)
deck progress: This one needs a lot of work, I do have some of the cards that are really good synergy peices, and then there are others that make the deck super clunky. I would like to make this one of my most efficient decks, within the top 3. I've already cut some because I realize how clunky they make it. (still want a little warhammer theme to it)

- Iroh, Grand lotus (I want this to be my number 2 deck, high efficency, pretty dominant/close to the highest win rate)
Objective: big lesson spells in the graveyard via draw and discard and then cast them for cheap or be able to cast things twice to get even more value out of them
bracket: 4
Deck Progress: Needs a bit more draw and discard engine of sculpting my hand and being able to choose what goes in the graveyard

- Avatar Aang
Objective: flip him using the four elements instead of using some gimmick while still having a huge ATLA theme in the deck
Bracket: 2
Deck Progress: I also feel as if this is a pretty successful first draft

- Grist, Voracious Larva (proxy)(more synergistic than the bracket would suggest, but still fun self mill gambling)
Objective: Self mill and make a ton of bugs, then bring stuff back and thump everyone via the ult
Bracket: 2
Deck Progress: This is one that I haven't playtested much, so let me know how it is and I'll go from there

- Baxter, Fly in the Ointment(I want this to be my best deck)
Objective: Draw all the cards in my deck and proliferating counters
Bracket: 4
Deck Progress: I Just put as many gamechangers as possible and edhrec'd most of it

- Sephiroth, Fabled Soldier (Need help with this one the most)
Objective: I want to make it so I can control the board while also utilizing the stuff I make my opponents put in the graveyard, like a "no you can't use it, but I can" type of deck. maybe even adding a little bit of everybody mill to have more targets as well. (I pulled his full art out of a pack so he will be in the deck, would prefer if he was the commander. Though I am open to suggestions)
Bracket: 3
Deck Progress: I have some of the plan down. (I ain't got jacks***, help)

I wont list the 8th deck, because it's gonna be my pack deck. The cards I get from packs will help improve that deck and it will help me work on my deck building skills. I also kinda just want it to be a brain child with my friends and a mystery. all the other cards that aren't able to be a part of this deck though, Ill give to people for free or half the usual price. Again, magic is a card game that should be fun and not cost an arm and a leg for a piece of card board so if I'm able to make decks better and have more fun playing the game, I'm more than willing to give those cards away.
Bracket: nope
Deck Progress: nah

Some of the decks are going to get pricey which I understand, but if it is possible please try and find relatively non-expensive options. However, I am down to spend a little more if it makes the deck function better and , of course, look a little cooler since these will be my last decks ever. if these decks end up being more expensive, this goal of mine may just take longer. which I am okay with

I wanted to try and build these myself, but I feel like I'm just using edhrec and not really going through all the options. So what better way to make my decks better than ask people for help. I have an Archidekt account and I would love some feed back on how these decks could possibly get even better or more synergistic according to the themes I want. Also, i can admit I'm not the best magic player so if you have any tips or tricks on how to improve as a magic player please let me know, I'm always willing to learn. The archidekt account is Honse_352. Any feedback will be taken into consideration and is much appreciated.

P.S. I'm not gonna be able to implicate every strategy or use every card you can think of, so please try and agree on cuts and adds to these decks, and I would like the help to be from HUMAN perspective(No AI BS). Also I will only be buying singles until the RELEASE of Kamigawa Titanbreach. so if you are seeing this after and have recommendations for these decks, I will likely not making any more cuts or adds.