I've been playing for about 3 years now so I'm definitely still a newer player and maybe my perspective is just wrong. But what prompted this post were the new Dune Secret Lair cards. I'm a big Dune guy but I just didn't feel all that excited from reading the cards. The Maud'Dib legendary creature feels like a card I've seen a hundred times. Something something look at the top of your library, play cards off the top when synergy is met, lands, graveyard, meh. It feels like every set regardless of the actual flavor has some effect that doubles things, some effect that cheats things into play, some effect that loads up the graveyard. And everything seems to reward you for engaging in basic game mechanics.
I wasn't playing when Storm and Dredge were originally printed as new mechanics, but they feel like they invented entirely new ways to play the game. Non-standard strategies you'd have to build around, or like a new axis of play.
I dunno. This could be really unpopular. I just can't shake the feeling that we're getting the same types of cards over and over again.