r/mtg • • 10m ago

Discussion Worst deck in competitive?

0 Upvotes

What was the worst deck ever in competitive Mtg?


r/mtg • • 19m ago

Discussion 2026 Set Rankings

0 Upvotes

Here is my set list rankings of MTG sets for this year. Feel free to add yours. I use 6 pillars to decide how to grade a set they are:

  1. Impact on Standard
  2. Impact on Modern/Eternal
  3. Impact on Commander
  4. Limited Enviroment
  5. Mechanics
  6. Set Aesthetics (Art, Small vs Large set, Reprints etc)

These are not all weighted equally for me 3-5 have a higher weight(1.5x), then 1 and 2(1x) and lastly 6 is .75. I rank these out of 5 and do give halfs and quarters so 4.5, 4.25, 4.75 are all rankings possible. So without further adieu

8. The Hobbit

7. Lorwyn Eclipsed

6. TMNT

5. Star Trek

4. Secrets of Strixhaven

3. Marvel Superheroes

2. Mystery Booster Commander

  1. Reality Fracture

I know there is a lot of UB haters out there and people will either not include or put that all last but i try to be constructive about my criticism. At the end of the day i love magic regardless what i think of these sets. Feel free to post your own thoughts. If your wondering how i came up with anything feel free to ask


r/mtg • • 25m ago

Commander / EDH I Made a Sonic the Hedgehog Deck, Looking for Thoughts and Advice

Post image
5 Upvotes

Hello!

Quite some time ago, I made a post asking for advice on how I could go about building a Sonic the Hedgehog deck. Since then, I've finally put the deck together and gotten a good amount of games in with it!

It's been pretty fun overall, but I feel there's still plenty of room for improvement. So, I thought I'd share my decklist and get some feedback from you all!

There are two things in particular I'd like to hear your thoughts on:

  1. How do you think the deck performs in its current state? Are there any obvious weaknesses, shortcomings, or areas where you think it could be improved?
  2. How would you go about improving it? Whether that means replacing specific cards, removing some entirely, or simply suggesting cards that you think might be worth considering, I'm open to just about anything!

Any advice, suggestions, or even just general opinions on how I've done as a beginner deckbuilder would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks for taking the time to read, and hopefully help!

the decklist:

[commander]: sonic the hedgehog (colors, red white and blue)

[lands]:

10 plains

10 mountains

10 islands

path of ancestry

port town

exotic orchard

master emerald shrine (command tower)

rogue's passage

[rest of the deck]:

selfless spirit

combat celebrant

legion loyalist

super state

amulet of vigor

mass hysteria

open the armory

forth eorlingas!

arclight phoenix

viashino firstblade

ring of evos isle

wear/tear (duo card)

miles "tails" prower

goldspan dragon

magda, brazen outlaw

rabbit battery

chaos warp

unexpected windfall

crackle with power

mindlink mech

piko piko hammer (hammer of nazalm)

ring of thune

qiqirn merchant

kratos' rage (pyrohemia)

flamewake phoenix

counterspell

adult gold dragon

scorpion sentinel

into the fire

loyal apprentice

swords to plowshares

academy manufactor

knuckles the echidna

arcane signet

fellwar stone

gallia the merrymaker

knuckles's gloves (the reaver cleaver)

thrill of possibility

village bell-ringer

chromatic lantern

commander's sphere

Tornado, sonic's biplane (weatherlight)

fanatical firebrand

aerith rescue mission

swallowed by leviathan

amy rose

air shoes (swiftfoot boots)

sol ring

felldar retreat

master warcraft

phoenix chick

fire magic

path to exile

phoenix of ash

Fabricate

dualcaster mage

abzan falconer

blasphemous act

pyroclasm

generous gift

frostcliff siege

coastal piracy

power sneakers (lightning greaves)

anger


r/mtg • • 32m ago

Apparel / Products Was super lucky to hold this card

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

The owner of my local LGS was generous enough to show me his blinged out witherbloom deck. Pictured is a few of the cards.
Definitely very cool to see cards like these.
I love this community for this fact- being generous enough to show it off even if the deck costs around $6,500


r/mtg • • 42m ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Recommendations for better decks?

1 Upvotes

I've been playing MTG for about a year or two now, so I'm still fairly new and learning as I go. My current deck is focused on spellcasting, but I've been playing against people who have decks with really fast mana ramp and powerful board wipes, and I'm struggling to keep up.

I've been thinking about trying something different, possibly a mono-red or mono-black deck. Ideally, I'd like something that's powerful, can build up mana fairly quickly, and has access to some good board wipes or other ways to control the battlefield.

I'd also really like to keep things relatively simple. I'm not looking for a deck with a bunch of complicated combos or mechanics that are difficult to keep track of. I'd prefer something straightforward, easy to learn, but still strong enough to hold its own against more powerful decks.

I'm still learning about different deck types and strategies, so I'd love to hear some recommendations! What decks or commanders would you suggest?


r/mtg • • 53m ago

Discussion Marvel Countdown Kit Post-Release Price Breakdown.

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/mtg • • 58m ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Collector Booster Gift Suggestions

0 Upvotes

A number of years ago I made the financially unfortunate decision of introducing my kids to MTG, a game I started playing in ‘93 (no, I did not have the wisdom to hold on to those cards). Now they have become pretty avid collectors, enjoying both deck building and collecting/selling/trading.

For Christmas I want to get both of them an assortment of Collector Booster packs to draft. I was thinking about 12 assorted packs for the two of them. My budget is about $700cad. I’ll probably be ordering from TCGplayer if I can’t find what I want locally (Vancouver).

I’m hoping you guys can make some suggestions for sets to draw from that offer the best opportunities in terms of rarity, coolness, usability…

Thanks!


r/mtg • • 1h ago

Commander / EDH Help me cut 30 cards from this deck.

0 Upvotes

Mono green ramp/stompies. I know that one worm from Dune isn't legal yet.

https://archidekt.com/decks/28575404/mono_green


r/mtg • • 1h ago

Custom Card / Alter Fish Custom Token

Post image
5 Upvotes

I saw that in Nauctis there will be Fish tokens, so I finished the one I was drawing a while ago.


r/mtg • • 1h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Christmas present for boyfriend

4 Upvotes

hi!! i’ll cut to the chase— my boyfriend is a big mtg nerd (lovingly) and i know NOTHING about it, but we both want me to be able to get into it and play it with him. i know so little about it that i have no idea how to buy him mtg related things, because i know it’s very involved and can depend on the person. i’m trying to keep what i’m getting him for xmas a total surprise, so i wanna avoid asking him probing questions regarding mtg so he doesn’t clock it. if i have to, i will, but i want to see if someone can help me with a general idea of what to look at before doing that. i’m willing to spend up to around $150. any advice would be appreciated!

edit: thank you to everyone who’s replied so far! i have just figured out that he technically has always played standard, but he wants to play commander since that’s what everyone seems to be doing nowadays. so ALL he has is standard stuff!


r/mtg • • 1h ago

Discussion Foil lines on all my foil cards from booster box

Post image
21 Upvotes

Did i just get really unlucky or is this a wide spread issue with this set?


r/mtg • • 1h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Cards being a specific card type everywhere BUT the library?

Post image
12 Upvotes

Can I somehow have a "creature" thats not a creature in the library? This would allow me to have a trigger for possibility storm, but when the card is in the library, it wouldn't be fetched by it.

Alternatively somehow putting my Commander in my Hand would also work lol


r/mtg • • 1h ago

Discussion First legit pull. Out of the Costco bundle.

Thumbnail gallery
283 Upvotes

Pretty excited to pull something like this out of a $50 kit.


r/mtg • • 2h ago

Commander / EDH Maelstrom Wanderer with a randomized creature package. Looking for suggestions!

0 Upvotes

Hey!

I'm brewing a Maelstrom Wanderer with fixed cards as the core, with the remaining slots randomly filled from a much larger pool of big, splashy creatures and spells (mostly 5-7 mv).

I want to include creatures/spells that are fun to hit off cascade or benefit from Wanderer's haste, including some cards that are normally a bit too janky or things that will be fun. I also want the deck to still be consistent at around b3 tables (my goal was b2 but I heard that he is kinda too splashy for that bracket).

I'd love some suggestions for the creature pool, as well as feedback on the current core.
Here is my list:
https://moxfield.com/decks/OPmhATOU5naemmg3AQm8sA


r/mtg • • 2h ago

Discussion Costco Magic for sale

Post image
146 Upvotes

Is this worth it at $74 CAD?


r/mtg • • 2h ago

Discussion CVS Magic cards

Post image
72 Upvotes

My CVS is having a “sale” but it’s really just the normal 6$ price for these packs, I normally buy them for 6$ that’s now I know, but the old label is still there


r/mtg • • 3h ago

Custom Card / Alter I made a custom OMORI themed commander deck! (MAJOR SPOILERS FOR OMORI) Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

All art is by OMOCAT, the developers of OMORI, so I don't take credit for any of that, but I made and designed all 100 cards, including custom basic lands, for an OMORI themed deck!

It was made with both OMORI and SUNNY in mind as possible commanders!

I have made a full 100 card deck with the 3 emotion cards as custom rules references, and with some creature tokens, but this is just a few of the key/coolest cards in my mind as a little preview

The deck is fully custom with no official magic cards (apart from basic lands I suppose) so this is obviously not for official play or anything, just casual commander fun :3


r/mtg • • 3h ago

Custom Card / Alter Bulbasaur plant token

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

Watercolor and ink, thank you for looking!


r/mtg • • 3h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help Is limiting myself to 60 cards or close to it hurting my deck building?

22 Upvotes

I normally play at home standard games and try not having more than 60 cards in my deck. This might be a bad habit from Yugioh, but I have this philosophy where if I need more than the minimum, then I probably don't have an efficient deck.

Is this true with Magic as well or is there a different idea that I should think about when deck building or do I just need more experience?


r/mtg • • 3h ago

Discussion What do you use Dragon's Approach to grab?

Post image
76 Upvotes

I am theory crafting a dragon's approach deck but am struggling to find a payoff. Originally I was stupid and thought [[Progenitus]] was a dragon. So reworking the deck, what is a good payoff for approach?


r/mtg • • 3h ago

Discussion 2026 the good, the bad, the ugly. Let’s talk about it

0 Upvotes

I was going to start this two days ago, and then the insufferable industry plant dropped his wotc preferred list for the sets of 2026, so I figured I’d stir the pot. “Influencer status” aside, what are your takes the sets of 2026.

I am not here to yuck someone else’s yum. While I may not support some of the business practices, I do support the game itself, and the people who play. And this is a discussion to hear everyone’s thoughts. For background, I started playing magic in alpha, and have been loosely on and off, but seriously got back into it four years ago. I build mostly commander, because that’s what is available and no one plays standard near me anymore. But I feel Prerelease is truly some of the best magic, and go to each event to get a feel for each set. And I love Universes Beyond, but i feel like they don’t get the same treatment from core sets, and get labeled as slop due to the mass production. So worst to first, let’s get after it.

8. Mystery commander- personally, I’ve got no time for this. This admittedly is a bunch of rejects that didn’t make standard legal sets, wrapped up with a fancy foil sleeve and charged a premium. This is prime corporate greed. If you sit down with a deck of 3000 cards or any other rule breaker, count me out. I just don’t find this fun, and fundamentally a disservice to you the player.

7- The Hobbit- Boom. Worst set this year. And I will readily admit that part of this decision is weighted on the audacity of the pricing. And before we move on, if the One Ring wasn’t reprinted, would this set be anywhere close to that? The archetypes were meh, kinda boring and listless, and genuinely a letdown. I accidentally bought a booster box, and when I finally opened it, was thoroughly underwhelmed with what was there. Now I will never turn down the addition of more elves to add to the ball, and there are some gorgeous lands, but I got my gleaming splendor, and I’m gonna move on.

6- Star Trek- Now it’s still very new, and maybe time will tell, but this one kinda missed the mark for me. Artwork is a large proponent of the game to me, and this wasn’t it. Full art shocklands were rad. But the reprints shouldn’t be what holds up a set, and personally I think sheoldred and bristly bill got done dirty on this one. Also the autographed cards feel especially grimy. A lot of this scream to me “bad business practice” than what’s going to be good for the game. However, the borg are gonna be really cool, it’s just too bad that we probably won’t be going back for more borg cards in a Star Trek 2 series.

5. Lorwyn Eclipsed- this is hard for me, because I liked this a lot. It was beautiful. It’s whimsical. But it’s a little soft. There were so many great cards, for so many fun deck options, but a little underwhelming on their own. But I’ve got a handful thrown into all my decks at the moment. I like dance of the elements, but it never seems to pop for me, and I ultimately broke down auntie ool, because you get targeted very quickly, regardless of a weak board.

4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles- it’s my list I can do what I want. This was my most anticipated set of the year. I was a huge turtle fan as a kid, and was so stoked when it was announced. I do love this set, I’ve made a ton of decks surrounding it. But I do feel cheated at the same time. The turtle precon is my favorite precon to come out this year. It’s competitive out of the box, it’s fun, and you have so many choices and directions to go in. But the repetitiveness is insane. How many white Leonardos do you need to print? Could you not dig a little deeper?
As a sidenote, I went to 2 prerelease for this, and got unlucky and properly stumped both times. But still, I think this set gets unjustly hated for being turtles, when it should be getting disliked for not being given the same care, to say, secrets of strixhaven.

3. Marvel Superheroes- I could have dropped this lower, but there really were a lot of good, powerful cards in here. Again, I like UB, and this got treatment most similar to Final Fantasy than Spiderman. Summer is a hard time to release a card game, we’ve all seen an official excessive amount of marvel, and I think we can all agree secret lair needs a new cash cow. But it plays well, and again, it’s definitely raised the power creep. But it does it with the subtlety of a spiked bat.

2. Reality Fracture- these last two, I could be happy flip flopping repeatedly. When I heard I could get a blue Chandra, you already had me. This set plays into jaces mind of madness perfectly. There are more plays to be made, and a ton of creativity and thought of characters and lore and history, and then the implications of the butterfly effect in this reality. Its beautiful. And i like planeswalkers getting so much love. The commitment to the echo pairs is double-edged, where it’s awesome at first, but leads to an insane amount of doubles in my collection, but im going to mark this a win. I would have been happy with another month to this season.

  1. Secrets of Strixhaven- this set did so much right. The spells are crisp and clean, the characters are great. The choice of which collage you would represent, I proudly support Witherbloom. The art was great, and the mystical archives were amazing. It made reprints seamlessly feel like it should have been there from the start. I loved the Japanese cards, except I can’t read Japanese, but the art was phenomenal. This set fully surpassed my expectations, and I’m going to await a return to strixhaven.

So that’s mine. Tell me what you think you’d change, and let’s keep it clean. Remember that even if your opponent is playing UB, they are still playing magic. If anyone sees Ben bateman, kick him in the nuts for me.


r/mtg • • 4h ago

Commander / EDH Teval takes 7th place! This Commander is so fun to pick up and play! People hate going against it because you cant stop the reanimations once its tuned.

0 Upvotes

r/mtg • • 4h ago

I Have a Question / I need Help I think it's time

0 Upvotes

Over the past couple years I've really gotten into magic, I've made lifelong friends and had some great games that have come down to the wire. However, I can no longer ignore the financial burden it has taken. some of my decks prices have gotten out of control and I don't think it's healthy anymore. this is not me saying I want to quit, but rather I am asking for help

I am going go through all my decks and see which one's I really enjoy using and then sell the ones that I don't. I am going to then improve the decks I enjoy and get new ones. I know that sounds -contradictory to me saying I want to cut my spending on the product, but these decks will be the last one's I ever make and use. after I complete these I will no longer buy singles or massive amounts of packs to build commander decks, standard decks, or even participate in draft. I will buy a couple play boosters and one collector booster per release because I still like the product and I don't know where the money trail goes, but if my money somehow goes to artists that's fine with me. (There's also another reason for that but I'll get to it later)

The amount of decks I want is 8, no more, no less. Most of them will be centered around universes beyond cards, but that's what got me into the game and I think some of the sets have been pretty cool and had some great mechanics. If you're still reading this you probably are wondering what those commanders will be, They are:

- Bumi, Unleashed
Objective: make lands into creatures and hit people
bracket: 4 (only because of ashaya, it also has one gamechanger in seedborn muse and no tutors(heavily considering owning one just incase I feel like making it slighlty more competitive depending on the play group))
deck progress: needs work with constantly turning lands into creatures, but I don't know if I want to get away from earthbending too much, need a decent amount of help with this deck

- Abaddon the Despolier
Objective: deals tons of damage to then go through my deck like a slot machine in a casino and spit out demons like a portal to the underworld
bracket: 3(Jeskai's will, cyclonic rift, rhystic study.)
deck progress: This one needs a lot of work, I do have some of the cards that are really good synergy peices, and then there are others that make the deck super clunky. I would like to make this one of my most efficient decks, within the top 3. I've already cut some because I realize how clunky they make it. (still want a little warhammer theme to it)

- Iroh, Grand lotus (I want this to be my number 2 deck, high efficency, pretty dominant/close to the highest win rate)
Objective: big lesson spells in the graveyard via draw and discard and then cast them for cheap or be able to cast things twice to get even more value out of them
bracket: 4
Deck Progress: Needs a bit more draw and discard engine of sculpting my hand and being able to choose what goes in the graveyard

- Avatar Aang
Objective: flip him using the four elements instead of using some gimmick while still having a huge ATLA theme in the deck
Bracket: 2
Deck Progress: I also feel as if this is a pretty successful first draft

- Grist, Voracious Larva (proxy)(more synergistic than the bracket would suggest, but still fun self mill gambling)
Objective: Self mill and make a ton of bugs, then bring stuff back and thump everyone via the ult
Bracket: 2
Deck Progress: This is one that I haven't playtested much, so let me know how it is and I'll go from there

- Baxter, Fly in the Ointment(I want this to be my best deck)
Objective: Draw all the cards in my deck and proliferating counters
Bracket: 4
Deck Progress: I Just put as many gamechangers as possible and edhrec'd most of it

- Sephiroth, Fabled Soldier (Need help with this one the most)
Objective: I want to make it so I can control the board while also utilizing the stuff I make my opponents put in the graveyard, like a "no you can't use it, but I can" type of deck. maybe even adding a little bit of everybody mill to have more targets as well. (I pulled his full art out of a pack so he will be in the deck, would prefer if he was the commander. Though I am open to suggestions)
Bracket: 3
Deck Progress: I have some of the plan down. (I ain't got jacks***, help)

I wont list the 8th deck, because it's gonna be my pack deck. The cards I get from packs will help improve that deck and it will help me work on my deck building skills. I also kinda just want it to be a brain child with my friends and a mystery. all the other cards that aren't able to be a part of this deck though, Ill give to people for free or half the usual price. Again, magic is a card game that should be fun and not cost an arm and a leg for a piece of card board so if I'm able to make decks better and have more fun playing the game, I'm more than willing to give those cards away.
Bracket: nope
Deck Progress: nah

Some of the decks are going to get pricey which I understand, but if it is possible please try and find relatively non-expensive options. However, I am down to spend a little more if it makes the deck function better and , of course, look a little cooler since these will be my last decks ever. if these decks end up being more expensive, this goal of mine may just take longer. which I am okay with

I wanted to try and build these myself, but I feel like I'm just using edhrec and not really going through all the options. So what better way to make my decks better than ask people for help. I have an Archidekt account and I would love some feed back on how these decks could possibly get even better or more synergistic according to the themes I want. Also, i can admit I'm not the best magic player so if you have any tips or tricks on how to improve as a magic player please let me know, I'm always willing to learn. The archidekt account is Honse_352. Any feedback will be taken into consideration and is much appreciated.

P.S. I'm not gonna be able to implicate every strategy or use every card you can think of, so please try and agree on cuts and adds to these decks, and I would like the help to be from HUMAN perspective(No AI BS). Also I will only be buying singles until the RELEASE of Kamigawa Titanbreach. so if you are seeing this after and have recommendations for these decks, I will likely not making any more cuts or adds.


r/mtg • • 4h ago

Commander / EDH My friend needs help

7 Upvotes

She wants to build a black white deck thats nothing but board wipes and removal and a bunch of creatures that pings for each creature that dies and she wants her commander to ping damage each time a creature dies ive tried recommending other colors but shes dead set on black white and I can only find commanders that pings when her creatures die not when any creature dies