r/languagelearning • u/Chezzik • 9h ago
Considering joining Duolingo again, now that Max features have been rolled back into the Super plan...
I know you guys all love to hate on Duolingo, so I'm sure you will be quick to point out all the problems here. That's fine. I can take it.
I still hate Duo because:
- They got rid of forums (seriously, I loved chatting about sentences with other real people)
- They took all the free work the Welsh community poured into the free Welsh lessons, and made it their own proprietary stuff, and then killed Welsh
- Woke garbage
- Their charter reason for existing (keep language learning free forever) is now a joke
- The dings and streaks annoy me. The app shouldn't be a casino
Quitting rationale:
But I begrudgingly paid for several years of Super (which was their highest tier). Once they made Max (a new highest level that was very expensive), they removed the guidebooks. The rationale was that we didn't need them to learn grammar, now that we could just pay for Max and ask AI! (sarcasm).
To make matters worse, I was suddenly getting ads again. They were all for Duolingo Max, which I had already decided I didn't want, but the ads were constant and overbearing. If the Super plan was cheap enough I would put up with such ads, but the ads were unacceptable for what I was paying.
This made me so mad that I finally decided to quit. They had already switched free plans from hearts (which could be earned) to energy (which runs out and can't be refilled), so I just quit completely, rather than deal with a completely useless free version. I played around with a few other competing apps for a bit, but eventually just stopped language learning altogether.
Why I'm considering coming back:
Now, my SO is wanting to learn Hatian Creole! She interacts with some Hatians, and wants to learn a bit. Most apps would never include such a niche language, but Duolingo does. We both tried the free version of Duo for about a week, and it is just as terrible as I assumed, but my SO is considering buying an account, just for learning this one language. I looked, and to my surprise Duolingo Max is gone! The Super Family plan is affordable, and the Max-specific features ("Explain my answer" and the AI chat system) are rolled into the lower tiers. I would still prefer the forums and guidebooks, but I find "Explain my answer" to be a somewhat acceptable replacement.
I do like the team quest stuff in Duolingo. Most of the gamification stuff is garbage, but I do like working with friends to complete quests, and now my SO would be on the app too. This is actually a big draw for me.
Before hitting that subscribe button, I just thought I'd post here and see what you all think. I hate giving this company even a dime of my money, so if you can convince me that something else would meet all my needs, then I'd be happy to do that instead.
Other options that I know of, or have tried
I don't think anything else out there meets my needs, but I am aware of:
- Anki decks. I actually use these for drilling on Chinese characters. They are free, but don't give a well-rounded plan for learning. I'll continue using it as an auxiliary resource.
- iTalki: Expensive, but probably the best way if you very serious about learning quickly. I find it intimidating, but I plan to do this eventually eventually with the 2 languages that I know the most. But Duo is always easier for casual learning (like while sitting on a train), so iTalki doesn't really meet my needs at this time.
- LingoPie: I love the idea, but I spend very little time watching TV or movies. Maybe some day I'll do it.
- HelloChinese: I prefer this to Duolingo, but as far as I know, they only have Mandarin Chinese.
- Memrise and Drops: Both are fun, but a bit shallow. I can't imagine actually gaining fluency with either of these.
- LingQ: I loved this the first day I tried it, but quickly soured. The stories are cringey and I didn't enjoy them. I loved the idea of learning a language by reading news in that language, but this feature just didn't work as well as I expected.
- AI: I frequently ask Gemini to explain things (using the free version in a browser). I have never tried speaking directly to an AI in a foreign language, but I know some people pay for an AI plan just to do this. This might be the best alternative I have to going back to Duo.
